Strategic Drafting With Patent Analytics Tools

Feb 17, 2021

Featured Image-Strategic Drafting with Patent Analytics Tools

There is a method to the madness of matching a USPTO patent examiner to each patent application. A lot happens before an examiner is assigned to a newly filed application. The USPTO first considers which team of examiners (called an “art unit”) is best suited to evaluate an application based on the type of invention the application describes, the underlying technological field and how the invention is framed by the drafting attorney. A single examiner is then chosen from within the qualified art unit, and patent prosecution proceeds from there. 

 The importance of understanding what goes on behind the scenes at the USPTO may not be obvious, but knowing why an application winds up on a specific examiner’s desk is a prerequisite to later influencing which examiner will be assigned to your application. By using USPTO statistics and analyzing USPTO data, patent practitioners have the power to strategically draft their applications to target the most favorable art units. 

Art Unit Statistics and Examiner Compositions 

At the time of filing, many patent applicants and patent practitioners alike fail to consider that all USPTO art units are different. With just a glance at art unit statistics using the LexisNexis PatentAdvisor® patent analytics platform, patent professionals come to understand that art units vary wildly in their allowance rates, prosecution lengths, appeal statistics and other critical metrics. Moreover, each art unit is unique in its proportions of “difficult,” “moderate and “easy” examiners.  

 The key to better performance throughout the patent process is acknowledging that a single application could be appropriately assigned to any one of several art units. By identifying an application’s potential art unit matches and which of those art units have the most applicant-friendly examiner proportions, patent professionals can then use analytics to draft applications to improve the odds that they will be reviewed by applicant-friendly examiners. 

 

Patent Application Chart

Aiming for a Better Art Unit

The language, terminology and framing used in drafting an application all influence which art unit the USPTO will choose as the best fit for evaluating the application. Before filing, PatentAdvisor™ users are able to analyze portions of their application drafts using the LexisNexis PathWays™ tool to determine which art units are likely to be assigned to the application. PatentAdvisor analytics also communicate which of those art units provide users with the best opportunity to receive a statistically favorable examiner. If a user’s draft is more likely to be assigned to a difficult group of examiners, PatentAdvisor can suggest the language that should be included and omitted from the document draft to help guide it to an art unit with a more favorable composition of examiners. 

 

 Understanding how art units are paired to applications is more meaningful than many patent practitioners may realize. Because each art unit differs in its relative difficulty, the fate of an application may depend on which art unit is chosen by the USPTO. Patent analytics tools like PatentAdvisor reveal the path an application is likely to take through the USPTOs process; but patent professionals can then use PatentAdvisor insights to steer their applications in a better direction. 

 

LexisNexis PathWays™ provides clear direction toward success when drafting patent applications. For more on how PathWays can improve patent drafting read LexisNexis PathWays™ for Art Unit Foresightdownload the fact sheet, and access the On-Demand Webinar Patent Application Targeting: How to Achieve the Best Classification Outcomes. 

 

For more on patent analytics, read Patent Analytics for Predictions, Performance and Evaluations, Part 1 and Part 2. Learn more about PatentAdvisor here. 

LexisNexis PatentAdvisor®

7 Day Trial

Get to know your examiner better with more context and a deeper understanding of your examiner’s behavior than ever available before.

With your free trial, you will gain instant access to:

Examiner Search allows you to search by examiner name for a filterable, examiner specific dashboard of patent analytics, including rejection specific statistics, appeal statistics, prosecution statistics, interview statistics, a backlog of RCEs and timeline.

QuickPair easily replaces the USPTO Public PAIR by providing the most robust application details anywhere, including examiner timeline, examiner allowance rate and the average time and number of office actions to allowance.

PatentAdvisor, the first-ever data-driven patent strategy tool, provides a systemic approach to crafting an effective prosecution strategy. Understand why certain patent applications take longer than others to reach allowance—then use that knowledge to devise better patent prosecution strategies.

Free Trial

Integration of Automation in the Patent Process

Automation has come a long way in a short amount of time, thanks to developments in big data, machine learning, robotics and the Internet of Things. Many people and businesses have grown accustomed to having software and machines perform tasks that humans once...

The Innovation Momentum 2022 Report Reflects Critical Global Topics and Highlights the Most Innovative Regions of the World

In a brand-new intellectual property report, we’ve revealed a unique methodology capturing the Innovation Momentum of the last two years and recognizing technology companies with exceptional technological relevance for the future and those outperforming their...

LexisNexis® acknowledges the world’s outperforming companies with its “Innovation Momentum 2022: The Global Top 100” report

“Innovation Momentum 2022: The Global Top 100” is the first patent-based report to measure short-term innovation momentum, recognizing innovators with exceptional technological relevance for the future and outperforming their peers.19 January 2021, New York, United...

How Ex Parte PTAB Decision Data Helps to Streamline Prosecution Processes

A distinguishing strength of a good patent practitioner is the ability to analogize or discern similarities. The problem is that finite hours are available for sifting through thousands of pages of online resources to find the needed information. This is where help...

LexisNexis® further champions the needs of patent professionals with new high-value dataset supporting more accurate and relevant prosecution guidance

LexisNexis® introduces new legal issue analysis for PTAB ex parte decisions in LexisNexis PatentAdvisor®, enabling search issue-tagged decisions and locating effective arguments at every interaction with the USPTO.11 January 2022, New York, United States – LexisNexis®...

Everything You Need to Know About 11/11 Aka Singles Day—The World’s Most Popular Online Shopping Day

By Xinyao Liu, Online Brand Protection Consultant 11/11, November 11th started as an unofficial holiday in China to celebrate single people. The holiday is referred to as Singles Day, Bachelor's Day, and double 11. In Chinese, a single person with no branches to the...