How to Compare Patent Prosecution Performances

May 24, 2021

Featured Image-How to Compare Patent Prosecution Performances

Comparing the effectiveness of two patent practitioners can be like comparing apples to oranges. The success of a patent application is dependent on many factors that are beyond a patent practitioner’s control, which makes it difficult to evaluate their performance throughout the patent process. For example, one might initially conclude that Practitioner A, who has an 80% patent allowance rate, is more successful than Practitioner B with a 70% allowance rate. However, it is hard to be certain who is more successful, since Practitioner A’s patent applications could have been evaluated by more patent-friendly patent examiners.  

 The LexisNexis PatentAdvisor® patent prosecution platform not only offers a solution for understanding USPTO patent examiner difficulty levels, but it also allows patent practitioners to communicate how their patent performance stacks up against competitors to help win over prospective clients. 

Normalizing Examiner Difficulty With PatentAdvisor ETA™ 

The biggest challenge in comparing the success of two patent practitioners is analyzing the difficulty of the patent examiners they have faced. Each USPTO patent examiner varies in their experience levels, the technologies they evaluate and their knowledge. To further complicate matters, each patent examiner’s difficulty level fluctuates throughout their career. Traditional  patent statistics fail to account for all of these variables, and can therefore, be poor gauges of examiner difficulty. Determining patent examiner difficulty levels can be done with an original patent metric produced using a sophisticated algorithm that takes into account the circumstances surrounding patent prosecution; more specifically, the PatentAdvisor ETA exclusive metric. 

 With PatentAdvisor™, users can access each USPTO patent examiner’s ETA value to determine their relative difficulty compared to all other USPTO patent examiners. Higher ETA values are associated with difficult patent examiners and indicate long patent prosecution durations and higher volumes of office actions. The PatentAdvisor platform also labels patent examiners as either “green,” “yellow” or “red” based on their ETA scores, which allows users to quickly determine if their assigned examiners are relatively easy, moderate or difficult, respectively. 




PatentAdvisor Efficiency Score™ and Practitioner Performance

With an effective way of determining USPTO examiner difficulty levels, the opportunity to evaluate the performance of patent practitioners presents itself. A measure of examiner difficulty levels produces a better understanding of how patent prosecution is likely to proceed against a specific patent practitioner. PatentAdvisor compares the actual performance of each patent application against its expected performance, and the performance is then scored based on how far it exceeds or falls below expectations. The scores of all the patent applications prosecuted by a patent practitioner are then combined to produce their Efficiency Score™the best basis for comparing the performances of patent practitioners. 


Overall Score


Without PatentAdvisor ETA and Efficiency Score metrics comparing patent practitioners can be like comparing apples to oranges. PatentAdvisor proprietary algorithms and patent metrics help users evaluate examiner difficulties and performances against individual USPTO patent examiners. With objective measures of success in patent prosecution, patent practitioners can better evaluate their performances against those of competing practitioners, helping them to better present themselves and win over prospective patent clients. 


 To learn more about examiner typestheir effect on the number of patents issued each year, and the relationship between the examiner types and the effort required to obtain a patent read How USPTO Examiner Type Affects Patents. To learn more about the Efficiency Score read Opportunities to Win with Patent Analytics and to learn more about Patent Advisor ETA read Overcoming Patent Examiner Variability: Three Key Takeaways 


Download the PatentAdvisor ETA datasheet here 

LexisNexis PatentAdvisor®

Two-Day Trial

Get to know your examiner better with more context and a deeper understanding of your examiner’s behavior than ever available before.

With your free trial, you will gain instant access to:

Examiner Search allows you to search by examiner name for a filterable, examiner specific dashboard of patent analytics, including rejection specific statistics, appeal statistics, prosecution statistics, interview statistics, a backlog of RCEs and timeline.

QuickPair easily replaces the USPTO Public PAIR by providing the most robust application details anywhere, including examiner timeline, examiner allowance rate and the average time and number of office actions to allowance.

PatentAdvisor, the first-ever data-driven patent strategy tool, provides a systemic approach to crafting an effective prosecution strategy. Understand why certain patent applications take longer than others to reach allowance—then use that knowledge to devise better patent prosecution strategies.

Free Trial

LexisNexis는 전 세계 조직이 UN SDGs에 대한 혁신 기여도를 객관적으로 추적하고 보고할 수 있도록 하는 새로운 지속 가능한 혁신 측정 프레임워크를 출시합니다.

UN 지속 가능한 개발 목표 프레임워크에 대한 특허 데이터의 업계 최초 정렬은 지속 가능한 혁신 분석에 혁명을 일으켰습니다. 12 October 2021, New York, United States — LexisNexis® Legal & Professional은 글로벌 특허 시스템을 UN Sustainable에 매핑하여 지속 가능한 중심의 혁신을 식별하고, 검색하고, 추적할 수 있도록 하는 선도적인 지적 재산권 분석 솔루션인...

When IP Meets Sustainability: Mapping Patents to the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals

By Marco Richter, Global Lead Product & Customer Success, LexisNexis Intellectual Property Solutions  Once considered a matter for governments and international organizations like the United Nations (UN), sustainability is now unquestionably a topic of major...

LexisNexis 推出新的可持续创新衡量体系,助力全球组织客观地跟踪和报告其创新对联合国可持续发展目标的贡献

业内首创:将专利数据与联合国可持续发展目标框架相结合,为可持续创新分析带来革新美国纽约 2021 年 10 月 12 日电 – 律商联讯集团 (LexisNexis® Legal & Professional) 宣布推出基于 LexisNexis® PatentSight® 的知识产权分析解决方案的创新扩展,将全球专利制度与联合国可持续发展目标 (UN Sustainable Development Goals, UN SDGs)...

LexisNexis는 전 세계 조직이 UN에 대한 혁신 기여를 객관적으로 추적하고 보고할 수 있도록 하는 새로운 지속 가능한 혁신 측정 프레임워크를 출시합니다 SDGs.

業界初、特許データを国連のSDGsの枠組みにマッピングすることで、持続可能なイノベーションの分析に革命を起こします。2021年10月12日, 米国ニューヨーク — LexisNexis® Legal & Professionalは、同社の知的財産分析ソリューションを代表するLexisNexis® PatentSight®のイノベーティブな機能を発表しました。世界の特許を国連の持続可能な開発目標(UN...

LexisNexis launches new Sustainable Innovation Measurement framework enabling organizations globally to objectively track and report on innovation’s contribution to the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals

Industry-first alignment of patent data to the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals framework revolutionizes sustainable innovation analysis.12 October 2021, New York, United States — LexisNexis® Legal & Professional is pleased to announce the launch of an...